Having read Jon Katz's post on Billy's blog, and having already replied to it, I read it again and figured I needed to tackle the issue on my own blog, since I tend to have the view that roleplay is good and important in leagues, and it doesn't feel like Katz does.
His first point is that if a league is small then only 2-3 people dominate. I think that would happen anyhow if a league is small, and why wouldn't a small fed have 2-3 dominating characters and the rest are left to fend for themselves? I mean what gives the guys who aren't doing lots of Rp and working hard to advance their characters the right to be in the main event and hold the big title?
His other side of the issue is that if you got to much talent then you can't establish a dominating champion...Who says you can't? Sean Stevens is a dominating champion in my eyes, I'd say he's been well established...Beyond him I'd think Marcus Westscott has been put into a good position as the #1 contender, and I feel like The First, even with him being my own character, has been pretty well established as a solid face. Anthology always get raves from people after every card, I think EPW's whole upper-midcard teir has been well cemented.
I'm not saying I think EPW is 100% Rp based...I think angles and storylines outside Rp factor into matches, I think they have to in every league, if you just judge every match based on Rp then you lack any ability to build storylines or angles that lead to payoffs, there has to be some storyline arc that you're using as a justification for getting from point A to point B.
As for the '150 pound woman' and '75 pound midget' comments, I mean, shots at Lindsay Troy and Duchess are always good fun for the whole family, but honestly, who's Rp'ing these characters on FW.com currently? This is a strawman arguement against roleplaying. I'm a belt whore of the highest order and if somebody told me that The First was to small to be world champion because they never really bought Jeff Hardy as being a legit main eventer...Then odds are I'd work out a different gimmick for that league, because I myself want to win World Titles, and I'm not going to have my character hold me back from that. Now maybe the guy who Rp's the 75 pound midget doesn't want a World Title and would rather do all kinds of zany shit in the mid-card, to each their own.
The thing about this comment is, you would be upfront with the handler that you're never putting the World Title on that character because they don't fit your mold as a champion, and that's perfect with me, handlers and fed-heads should have open lines of communication where they express their opinons about characters and what they think they should be doing and where they are going with the character.
Rp has to matter because otherwise you are encouraging people to be lazy, you're fostering this mindset that it's OK to not do a bunch of Rp's because 'we're all adults now, we have jobs, families, lives' etc, when if people do give a damn about a league, we get 20+ posts in a tag title main event on EPW. I know that Siegel and I are nuts, but Garth stumbled off the street and in his first match put in his work to hang with everyone, and Jamar didn't slack either. It was the most fun I'd had in ages in a thread.
It was like the scene in "The Crow" where the main villian, the never named Top Dollar, declares he's done with Devil's Night because it's boring and cliche, and when finally asked if he doesn't want anyone to set a fire he says what he wants is a REALLY BIG FIRE, so that the Gods will notice us again...
It was to me, a stark contrast to the EPW World Title match at Wrestleverse. I know Straw only did one Rp because he was working out an angle for Rocko to lose first, and I know Holzerman had one foot out the door of E-Fedding at the time, and Jamar tends to Rp best when pushed by his opponents (see the tag thread and the thread for First/Stevens)...But that thread kind of hurt me, because Brunk had thought about putting The First in that match for a while before deciding against it, and then to see that lackluster level of Rp...It just killed me. People tend to poo-poo E-Fedding and give the whole 'It's just a game' or 'it's a silly hobby' mentality to things, but honestly, we do spend time at this, and we have goals to achieve in leagues, and when your goal is to be EPW Champion and you see a title match where there is merely 1 post from each guy and they call it a day...It's just like "AHHHHHHHH!!!!"
Basically I think Rp should matter a lot, because it shows your level of committment and caring to your league you're in, and if you put in work, it should be rewarded at some point. Angles and Storylines have to count also, because without a story to tell the Rp is just meaningless, but the Rp should effect who the stories are told about.
And as for TEAM...TEAM is to me a kind of 'one-off' event. Like a friendly between two nations in Soccer. It is it's own seperate thing and pretty much divorced from the other leagues, the bitching and yelling and crys of 'bullshit' about TEAM are based almost totally off the fact that we have no idea what the standards for judging Rp are, because we don't know who the judges are. That's about it. I think if Adam just handled all the matches or the judging panel was public it would be a lot better.
Now I'm gonna go do something productive with my time, such as farm herbs on my blood elf rogue.
Monday, June 8, 2009
Friday, June 5, 2009
Compete Vs cooperate and shooting
A lot of times in E-Fedding we come to a point where we really have to ask ourselves if this next match is really worth winning by going balls to the wall all out total Rp and angle war, or if it's a match that we would be better served by working out a deal with the opponent...
I think of Godbooks and storyline advancing matches as a sort of plea agreement between both sides..."The jury" is the fed head or bookers and in a bunch of matches you don't want your case going to them, cause you might just lose outright.
But the question is can you get something better out of working a deal. And can the deal help out both people in the match? This is really where E-Fedding is kind of weird, because a lot of times the opponent you're fighting to death today, is the guy you need to help you tomorrow.
I tend to think that if you're not in the World Title picture that odds are you should try to cut deals and work out storylines with as many people as you can to build yourself up to the point where you can fight for the World Title...And that on the whole, the World Title scene is going to be people competing against each other with no quarter given or asked, because this is what we're all trying to do, win the big belt.
I was reading Billy's blog and it talked about how I am both shot on, ("Brian") and am a shooter. My defense.
Mass murdering isn't generally a sold gimmick in any league I've been in, I can't imagine somebody trying to get over in EPW/NFW/LVW/WFW:NE/The Lucha Thing Ryan's Got Going/Etc. The Doc character could never accept this gimmick, because it's so stupid, and for as big of a business exposing jerk as he is, this is a bridge to far even for him.
A goth idiot...Is a goth idiot...First's first match had him refered to as a Michael Manson rip off...So I can't see how he's exposing the biz as it were. I know Billy covered all that, but I just wanted to say my own piece.
Also, as I've told anyone willing to listen to me for more then a minute about the gimmick, the person of Brian Nadalny is that of an idiot goth outcast who hung out with his gaggle of goth moron friends and around the age of 16, he had the epiphany that he had the soul of the first human being to get a soul put in them, and thusly in a night of weepie goth bullshit, got all his idiot friends to buy into his shit and call him First...
So he's really living the gimmick...There is a reason I call him a moron all the time. Hell I'd make fun of him if I was dealing with him.
I think of Godbooks and storyline advancing matches as a sort of plea agreement between both sides..."The jury" is the fed head or bookers and in a bunch of matches you don't want your case going to them, cause you might just lose outright.
But the question is can you get something better out of working a deal. And can the deal help out both people in the match? This is really where E-Fedding is kind of weird, because a lot of times the opponent you're fighting to death today, is the guy you need to help you tomorrow.
I tend to think that if you're not in the World Title picture that odds are you should try to cut deals and work out storylines with as many people as you can to build yourself up to the point where you can fight for the World Title...And that on the whole, the World Title scene is going to be people competing against each other with no quarter given or asked, because this is what we're all trying to do, win the big belt.
I was reading Billy's blog and it talked about how I am both shot on, ("Brian") and am a shooter. My defense.
Mass murdering isn't generally a sold gimmick in any league I've been in, I can't imagine somebody trying to get over in EPW/NFW/LVW/WFW:NE/The Lucha Thing Ryan's Got Going/Etc. The Doc character could never accept this gimmick, because it's so stupid, and for as big of a business exposing jerk as he is, this is a bridge to far even for him.
A goth idiot...Is a goth idiot...First's first match had him refered to as a Michael Manson rip off...So I can't see how he's exposing the biz as it were. I know Billy covered all that, but I just wanted to say my own piece.
Also, as I've told anyone willing to listen to me for more then a minute about the gimmick, the person of Brian Nadalny is that of an idiot goth outcast who hung out with his gaggle of goth moron friends and around the age of 16, he had the epiphany that he had the soul of the first human being to get a soul put in them, and thusly in a night of weepie goth bullshit, got all his idiot friends to buy into his shit and call him First...
So he's really living the gimmick...There is a reason I call him a moron all the time. Hell I'd make fun of him if I was dealing with him.
Monday, June 1, 2009
3 world champions, 9 dollars
Dealing the WSOP is surreal. It's truly jarring, you have the high stakes assholes who are just worthless pieces of shit who treat you like garbage. I got another one today, he was a prince. Just a loathsome worthless bastard who spent my whole half hour of dealing looking down his nose at me, doing everything he could to be a prick. These people have suffered the stunning realization that money doesn't make you happy and thusly spent their days making people as miserable as they are.
Of course all these people are cheap as can be, a bunch of stiffs, I made 19 dollars and had to give 10 of it back cause a game broke while I was dealing and the bank was off 10. Counting banks is next to impossible because you have these fuckers breathing down your neck the moment you sit down demanding action, while you're supposed to be counting down 1,000 dollars worth of chips in your bank.
That's the bad news, the good news is just how weird this event is, and what happens when you're here. My room mate and I are walking into the area where the WSOP is being dealt and as we're walking in, we see Dan Harrington walking the other way. A few moments later we see Peter Eastgate also walking the opposite way. To finish things up about a minute later we see Robert Varkonyi walking with his wife Olga. Just a run of the mill day for a couple WSOP dealers to see three main event champions walking around the halls of the Rio.
Hopefully tomorrow will be less asshole, more money.
Of course all these people are cheap as can be, a bunch of stiffs, I made 19 dollars and had to give 10 of it back cause a game broke while I was dealing and the bank was off 10. Counting banks is next to impossible because you have these fuckers breathing down your neck the moment you sit down demanding action, while you're supposed to be counting down 1,000 dollars worth of chips in your bank.
That's the bad news, the good news is just how weird this event is, and what happens when you're here. My room mate and I are walking into the area where the WSOP is being dealt and as we're walking in, we see Dan Harrington walking the other way. A few moments later we see Peter Eastgate also walking the opposite way. To finish things up about a minute later we see Robert Varkonyi walking with his wife Olga. Just a run of the mill day for a couple WSOP dealers to see three main event champions walking around the halls of the Rio.
Hopefully tomorrow will be less asshole, more money.
Saturday, May 30, 2009
BGT
Let it never be said I can predict anything.
I loved Diversity and am so glad they won, youtube all their performances, they are beyond excellent.
Shocked the saxophone player got third. I guess the brits didn't want another dancing kid to win it all again.
Boyle will still get a singing deal out of this so she's not hurting for the loss.
I loved Diversity and am so glad they won, youtube all their performances, they are beyond excellent.
Shocked the saxophone player got third. I guess the brits didn't want another dancing kid to win it all again.
Boyle will still get a singing deal out of this so she's not hurting for the loss.
WSOP day 2
Day 1 I got kicked out after 2 hours, it was boring.
Day 2 was my first real moment of being thrown into the fire, it was a kind of jarring. I'd dealt kiddie pool poker my whole career, 1-2 no limit, maybe a 2-5 every once in a blue moon. Here I was dealing 5-10 no limit with deep deep stacks. 5-10 Pot-Limit Omaha with people buying in for 2,000 a pop. It was really crazy the size of the bets and of course, with this much money comes assholes. I had one real piece of shit in the 4 seat at one table just give me a working over, he was one of those people you wish they would get shot, but not shot like now-a-days, I mean shot like in the revolutionary war when you got hit in the stomach and the doctors had no idea what to do about it just declared it was fatal and then you spent the next 12-48 hours in ripping agony before your body finally gave out on you.
The dealer ahead of me brutally screwed up the final pot, an all-in was called and he pushed the pot without counting down the size of the winning stack, and that led to a giant ordeal. I got into the game not knowing it was a timed game (We take 8 dollars per person per half hour as the rake) and thusly against the rules of WSOP, dealt a hand without taking time, when I tried to stop and take time the 4 seat screamed "We're not stopping in the middle of a hand for time!" and then everyone starting bitching about how the dealers suck, are idiots, morons, etc. They say all this shit without caring that you can hear then, cause they know you just have to take their shit.
From them I then dealt to Chris Moneymaker, who's a really nice guy, he tips, which is more then I can say for most people. His table was really cheerful and friendly, it was a good game all around.
I had more shitty table in the night, a bunch of not so happy people at a really boring 5-10 no limit game. One guy was whining about the game being slowed down by having a player only having 100's in front of him, it was good times.
I dealt a crazy 25-25 PLO game with the button straddling every hand for 50. A few players had 20,000 in front of them, but no hands ever got out of control in the PLO.
Just another one of the glorious days I'll be having at the series. More updates as I work.
Day 2 was my first real moment of being thrown into the fire, it was a kind of jarring. I'd dealt kiddie pool poker my whole career, 1-2 no limit, maybe a 2-5 every once in a blue moon. Here I was dealing 5-10 no limit with deep deep stacks. 5-10 Pot-Limit Omaha with people buying in for 2,000 a pop. It was really crazy the size of the bets and of course, with this much money comes assholes. I had one real piece of shit in the 4 seat at one table just give me a working over, he was one of those people you wish they would get shot, but not shot like now-a-days, I mean shot like in the revolutionary war when you got hit in the stomach and the doctors had no idea what to do about it just declared it was fatal and then you spent the next 12-48 hours in ripping agony before your body finally gave out on you.
The dealer ahead of me brutally screwed up the final pot, an all-in was called and he pushed the pot without counting down the size of the winning stack, and that led to a giant ordeal. I got into the game not knowing it was a timed game (We take 8 dollars per person per half hour as the rake) and thusly against the rules of WSOP, dealt a hand without taking time, when I tried to stop and take time the 4 seat screamed "We're not stopping in the middle of a hand for time!" and then everyone starting bitching about how the dealers suck, are idiots, morons, etc. They say all this shit without caring that you can hear then, cause they know you just have to take their shit.
From them I then dealt to Chris Moneymaker, who's a really nice guy, he tips, which is more then I can say for most people. His table was really cheerful and friendly, it was a good game all around.
I had more shitty table in the night, a bunch of not so happy people at a really boring 5-10 no limit game. One guy was whining about the game being slowed down by having a player only having 100's in front of him, it was good times.
I dealt a crazy 25-25 PLO game with the button straddling every hand for 50. A few players had 20,000 in front of them, but no hands ever got out of control in the PLO.
Just another one of the glorious days I'll be having at the series. More updates as I work.
Friday, May 29, 2009
The First Issue, and BGT
So I woke up today and I find myself suddenly in the mist of a random series of events as it appeared Josh, Rp'er of Anarky, had been driven to outrage over yet another "Brian" filled First Rp by a First opponent. Over the course of a series of PM's I hashed out the whole issue with Brunk and then posted a Brunk approved message on the forums about the ordeal.
I'm really sorry about everything and that's about all I can say.
Lastly I'm just like to restate again that First is such a total moron of a character I'd like to think I give people tons of ammo to use on him such that I'd hope calling him "Brian" would be about 1,000th on the list of weapons to use against him.
Now for far more important news, I've become a Britain's got talent mark (Soon to be an America's got talent mark once AGT comes back on) and so the big question really is.
Can Aidan Davis upset Susan Boyle?
Everything seems to be lining up for the young dancer, he won the last semi-final so he has the momentum going into the final, Boyle's been invovled in a bunch of sketchy off TV events that could hurt her, because Davis was on the last show, odds are he can just repeat his act, while people will expect Boyle to sing a new song and she might not do so well on it.
All this said...No, he can't beat her, nobody's stopping her...She's the story this year, so she's winning it. I hope I'm wrong cause I think Davis needs the win more then her, but I doubt it. (Note: I also had Cleveland winning the NBA title this year and that isn't looking so good.)
The top 3
1. Boyle
2. Davis
3. Diversity (edging out Flawless)
I'm really sorry about everything and that's about all I can say.
Lastly I'm just like to restate again that First is such a total moron of a character I'd like to think I give people tons of ammo to use on him such that I'd hope calling him "Brian" would be about 1,000th on the list of weapons to use against him.
Now for far more important news, I've become a Britain's got talent mark (Soon to be an America's got talent mark once AGT comes back on) and so the big question really is.
Can Aidan Davis upset Susan Boyle?
Everything seems to be lining up for the young dancer, he won the last semi-final so he has the momentum going into the final, Boyle's been invovled in a bunch of sketchy off TV events that could hurt her, because Davis was on the last show, odds are he can just repeat his act, while people will expect Boyle to sing a new song and she might not do so well on it.
All this said...No, he can't beat her, nobody's stopping her...She's the story this year, so she's winning it. I hope I'm wrong cause I think Davis needs the win more then her, but I doubt it. (Note: I also had Cleveland winning the NBA title this year and that isn't looking so good.)
The top 3
1. Boyle
2. Davis
3. Diversity (edging out Flawless)
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
Nomination for TEAM judge
What with the Supreme Court being in the headlines and the raging fight raging on Billy's blog via nameless people, I felt the need to step forth and offer my services after this tournament is over to be a full time judge on TEAM. I've become a mark for "Britain's Got Talent" over the last month or so and I really feel like TEAM should have 3 very public judges who go over all the matches and make their decisions.
People complain about losing all the time, it's one of the reasons we all get into this hobby, the feeling of being wronged is something I thing we all can really get into.
The problem is that when people lose in TEAM they blame "TEAM" this faceless entity that existed only to incorrectly judge the Rp in their match and give victory to the undeserving party. It's also deeply annoying to lose in TEAM because TEAM is just a straight Rp event, there is no angles to build off of a loss, no storylines to follow up, you lose and you're done, it's a pretty cold reality. You would like to at least understand the logic of why you lost, and public judges would help with that, cause they would have to explain themselves to the public for why they made the decision they did.
So why should I be trusted to judge TEAM? Well I've been in E-Fedding for forever and have seen just about everything, I spend way to much time on this hobby. I understand character development and the finer points of 'smacktalk' Rp, which is what TEAM is. And I have a pretty simple series of criteria for picking a winner.
1) Effort
Effort is what matters most to me, putting the first Rp up. Stacking somebody. I know people are always going on about 'quality vs quantity' and how 1 good Rp should beat 40 bad ones, but why is that? Good is subjective, I mean crap is crap and that's all there is to it, but if somebody gets off a solid first Rp, their opponent replies back with some epic Rp that makes me weep...And then the first guy writes another good reply, and then a stacking good reply...The first guys wins, he was hungry, he wanted it more, that's all there is to it...If you want to win, don't let yourself be stacked, 48 hours is plenty of time to get an Rp up, and this is TEAM, this is a pure Rp wins format, you know what you were getting into when you signed up.
2) Character
Your character is what you are portraying here, so I'd expect to see that, if I don't know your character I'll read your bio and then check out the league your from and read Rp's you've done to get a baseline for your character. Then I'd expect him to stay as that person. He might be fighting a total stranger, but that's something that often happens in TEAM. I want to see your guy being your guy thrown into this match.
"But you spent your whole time burying Christian Daniels for being a murderer"
That was as Doc Silver, hater of horrible gimmicks. As a judge if I'm judging his Rp's I want to see him killing people in clever ways so as to not be caught, I want "Christian Daniels, biker crime lord" rocking the bikerdom, and the crime lord...
3) The debate
This is a buncha smacktalking, I want you crushing your opponent's smacktalk in a coherent way that is true to your character, controlling the flow of the debate. When people don't have very solid talking points in their Rp's it generally means you skimmed your opponent's stuff. That's weaksause, read it and refute it.
4) Most overt pandering to my pet interests*
If it's really close and you're nervous about victory, pander shamelessly. Quote Garbage lyrics, go for B-sides and shit that's really obscure or I won't really feel like your trying. Talk about 'hand-range' and 'M' in relation to poker. Bring up the JFK assassination and who you think did it. Talk about Warcraft. Odds are it's 1-1 in the judging and I'm deciding if all your hard work is going to be rewarded or not, so you might as well placate me.
*= This is all a lie, none of this will help you.
Maybe I should have PM'ed Adam all this, but then I wouldn't have anything to blog about, and besides, I'd want it to be public anyhow, so I figured I'd post it here.
So that's that, off to await round 2 results and remember, if Doc jobs to Cruise it's the greatest outrage in the history of E-Fedding! Expect a redaction filled tirade right after I see that result!
(Or not. I can't honestly worry to much about matches where I'm writing friggin movie Rp's into the threads.)
People complain about losing all the time, it's one of the reasons we all get into this hobby, the feeling of being wronged is something I thing we all can really get into.
The problem is that when people lose in TEAM they blame "TEAM" this faceless entity that existed only to incorrectly judge the Rp in their match and give victory to the undeserving party. It's also deeply annoying to lose in TEAM because TEAM is just a straight Rp event, there is no angles to build off of a loss, no storylines to follow up, you lose and you're done, it's a pretty cold reality. You would like to at least understand the logic of why you lost, and public judges would help with that, cause they would have to explain themselves to the public for why they made the decision they did.
So why should I be trusted to judge TEAM? Well I've been in E-Fedding for forever and have seen just about everything, I spend way to much time on this hobby. I understand character development and the finer points of 'smacktalk' Rp, which is what TEAM is. And I have a pretty simple series of criteria for picking a winner.
1) Effort
Effort is what matters most to me, putting the first Rp up. Stacking somebody. I know people are always going on about 'quality vs quantity' and how 1 good Rp should beat 40 bad ones, but why is that? Good is subjective, I mean crap is crap and that's all there is to it, but if somebody gets off a solid first Rp, their opponent replies back with some epic Rp that makes me weep...And then the first guy writes another good reply, and then a stacking good reply...The first guys wins, he was hungry, he wanted it more, that's all there is to it...If you want to win, don't let yourself be stacked, 48 hours is plenty of time to get an Rp up, and this is TEAM, this is a pure Rp wins format, you know what you were getting into when you signed up.
2) Character
Your character is what you are portraying here, so I'd expect to see that, if I don't know your character I'll read your bio and then check out the league your from and read Rp's you've done to get a baseline for your character. Then I'd expect him to stay as that person. He might be fighting a total stranger, but that's something that often happens in TEAM. I want to see your guy being your guy thrown into this match.
"But you spent your whole time burying Christian Daniels for being a murderer"
That was as Doc Silver, hater of horrible gimmicks. As a judge if I'm judging his Rp's I want to see him killing people in clever ways so as to not be caught, I want "Christian Daniels, biker crime lord" rocking the bikerdom, and the crime lord...
3) The debate
This is a buncha smacktalking, I want you crushing your opponent's smacktalk in a coherent way that is true to your character, controlling the flow of the debate. When people don't have very solid talking points in their Rp's it generally means you skimmed your opponent's stuff. That's weaksause, read it and refute it.
4) Most overt pandering to my pet interests*
If it's really close and you're nervous about victory, pander shamelessly. Quote Garbage lyrics, go for B-sides and shit that's really obscure or I won't really feel like your trying. Talk about 'hand-range' and 'M' in relation to poker. Bring up the JFK assassination and who you think did it. Talk about Warcraft. Odds are it's 1-1 in the judging and I'm deciding if all your hard work is going to be rewarded or not, so you might as well placate me.
*= This is all a lie, none of this will help you.
Maybe I should have PM'ed Adam all this, but then I wouldn't have anything to blog about, and besides, I'd want it to be public anyhow, so I figured I'd post it here.
So that's that, off to await round 2 results and remember, if Doc jobs to Cruise it's the greatest outrage in the history of E-Fedding! Expect a redaction filled tirade right after I see that result!
(Or not. I can't honestly worry to much about matches where I'm writing friggin movie Rp's into the threads.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)